| Pastor |
Years |
| Father John Ingoldsby |
1850-1852 |
| Father Woulfe, OFM |
1852-1857 |
| Father Riordan |
1857 |
| Father Handy |
1857-1860 |
| Father James Largen |
1858-1869 |
| Father Richard Nagle |
1869-1873 |
| Father John Nuget |
1873 |
| Father Patrick O'Connell |
1873-1880 |
| Father Michael Gualco |
1880-1884 |
| Father B. Becker |
1884-1887 |
| Father P.J. Kline |
1887-1892 |
| Father Bernard McFeeley |
1892-1902 |
| Father Denis Horgan |
1902-1920 |
| Father O'Flanagen |
1920 |
| Monsignor Thomas J. Hayes |
1920-1952 |
| Father Joseph Hanrahan |
1952-1961 |
| Monsignor Cornelius F. O'Connor |
1961-1968 |
| Father Thomas O'Brien |
1968-1979 |
| Monsignor Patrick Nolan |
1979-1983 |
| Father Anthony Gurnell |
1983-1995 |
| Father John Sullivan |
1995-2000 |
| Father John Cantwell |
2000-2013 |
| Reverend Hernando Gomez-Amaya |
2014- |